If you finished Musafir Cafe and want another café-set Indian love story, try The Café Across Carter Road: Not Your Typical Bombay Love Story by Yash Gadade. It’s a slow-burn, dual-timeline Mumbai romance ebook in which two readers fall in love through anonymous notes left in library books. Musafir Cafe is a reflective story built on an arranged-marriage meeting and a second chance. Carter Road is a warmer, funnier story built on letters and books.
Musafir Cafe is everywhere right now thanks to its Netflix adaptation. If it left you wanting more café-set Indian romance, this comparison will help you choose what to read next.
I wrote the second one, so I’m biased. I’ll be as fair as I can, because both books are about the same thing from different angles: what happens when two people keep returning to the same room.
Musafir Cafe is everywhere right now, thanks to its Netflix adaptation. If it left you wanting more café-set Indian romance, this comparison of Musafir Cafe vs The Café Across Carter Road will help you choose what to read next.
I wrote the second one, so I’m biased. I’ll be as fair as I can, because both books are about the same thing from different angles: what happens when two people keep returning to the same room.
The Premise
Musafir Cafe: According to the series synopsis, Chander, a pragmatic software engineer, meets Sudha, a blunt divorce lawyer, at a traditional arranged-marriage meeting. Sudha is upfront that marriage isn’t in her plans, and the story follows the pair across timelines, including Chander’s café in Mussoorie and an unresolved past.
The Café Across Carter Road: Adi is an intern and aspiring novelist who spends his evenings at a library café on Carter Road in Bandra. Fatima is an illustrator who loves books too. They never exchange names. Instead they leave anonymous notes in the margins of the books they pass along through the café’s keeper, Harshita. The romance grows through those margins long before either dares to speak directly.
Where They Overlap
- The café is the heart of the story. In both, it’s where people pause, remember and change.
- Love isn’t tidy. Both books resist the instant-chemistry formula.
- Modern Indian relationships. Careers, family expectations and timing all matter.
- Realistic conversation. The dialogue sounds like people, not poetry.
Where They Differ
Setting. Musafir Cafe moves between the hills and other cities. Carter Road stays in one city, Mumbai, and treats it almost like a third lead.
The way love begins. One starts with a formal meeting between two people who already know the stakes. The other starts with two strangers who know nothing about each other except what they write in the margins.
Tone. Musafir Cafe leans reflective and emotionally complex. Carter Road is a gentle slow burn that keeps its humour.
Format. Musafir Cafe has a Netflix adaptation. Carter Road is a standalone ebook, so you can start reading it today.
Get Your Copy!
Some love stories aren’t spoken out loud. They’re left in the margins, waiting to be found. Adi first notices her from across Carter Road, on Mumbai’s Bandra promenade, a stranger under a yellow umbrella, watching the sea while he stares at a blank manuscript.
What Makes the Carter Road Book Different
The notes. The core hook is simple: two readers fall for each other without names. One of Fatima’s early notes says that “evenings that let you finish something slowly are harder to find than they should be in this city.” You can read that as a line about books, or as a line about love.
The city. Every location in the book is a place I actually spend time in, from Subko in Pali Village to Khau Galli in Ghatkopar. The glossary explains Mumbai words like Ba, fafda and Marine Drive for readers from elsewhere, so you don’t need to know the city to enjoy it.
The structure. The book runs on two timelines, and Part Two, “Between the Pages,” holds the chapter “The Girl in the Café.”
The pace. The book trusts the slow build. The Part Two epigraph sums it up: “We fall for people the way we fall for books — a little at a time, and then all at once, somewhere around the chapter we didn’t see coming”
Which Should You Read?
- Choose Musafir Cafe if you want a reflective story about love, ambition and second chances, or you want the source of the series.
- Choose The Café Across Carter Road if you want a warm, funny, slow-burn Mumbai romance built around books and letters.
- Read both if you love café love stories. They’re very different books and don’t compete.
FAQ
Are Musafir Cafe and The Café Across Carter Road connected?
No. They’re separate books by different authors.
What is The Café Across Carter Road about?
It’s a slow-burn Mumbai romance about Adi, an intern and aspiring novelist, and Fatima, an illustrator. They fall in love through anonymous notes left in the margins of library books at a Carter Road café in Bandra, without ever exchanging names.
Who wrote The Café Across Carter Road?
Yash Gadade, an Indian author and blogger based in Mumbai. The book is subtitled Not Your Typical Bombay Love Story.
Is The Café Across Carter Road a romcom?
Yes. It’s a slow-burn romantic comedy with a bookish, letter-driven premise and a gentle sense of humour, set across two timelines.
Is there a book similar to Musafir Cafe?
If you want another café-set Indian romance, The Café Across Carter Road shares the café setting and the grounded, modern take on Indian relationships. It differs in setting (Mumbai, not Mussoorie), tone (lighter, funnier) and how the couple connects (anonymous notes).
Where is The Café Across Carter Road set?
Mostly in Mumbai, across Carter Road and Bandra, Pali Village, Marine Drive and Ghatkopar’s Khau Galli.
Is there a sequel to the Carter Road book?
The author’s note says what happens next is coming soon.
Which is better for first-time Indian romance readers?
Either works. If you like gentle humour and a clear setting, start with Carter Road.
Do I need to know Mumbai to read it?
No. The book includes a glossary of Mumbai words and places.
Where can I buy The Café Across Carter Road?
It’s available as an ebook. Click Here